Learn from the past.
Prepare for the future.
Tracking the global digital assets ecosystem

Launching an ETF is Easier Than Ever, But Building a Commercially Successful ETF Remains Complex 

By Daryn Levesque, Director and COO, PINE Advisor Solutions – a Centralis company 

Daryn Levesque

The US ETF market has experienced significant growth in recent years. According to the Investment Company Institute, ETF assets reached $16.15 trillion in September 2026, an increase of 27.8% year on year. Investment managers that traditionally focused on mutual funds and private funds are increasingly entering the ETF market to reach new investors and expand their offerings. 

This growth can be attributed, at least in part, to regulatory changes that have lowered barriers to entry, and advances in technology making certain aspects of fund launches, such as preparing offering documentation, faster and more efficient. 

However, launching an ETF and building a commercially successful fund are two very different things. Whether an ETF is actively or passively managed, its success depends on much more than investment strategy. Even experienced investment managers may be unfamiliar with the additional responsibilities involved in operating an ETF, and overlooking these requirements can prove costly for both managers and shareholders. 

Understanding the secondary market 

One of the most significant differences between ETFs and traditional mutual funds is how investors buy and sell their shares. 

Mutual fund investors typically transact directly with the fund, at the net asset value (NAV) calculated at the end of each trading day. ETFs, by contrast, trade on stock exchanges throughout the day, with investors generally buying and selling shares from one another at market prices. 

This introduces considerations that may be unfamiliar to managers accustomed to operating different fund structures such as mutual funds or private funds. Regardless of whether a fund is actively or passively managed, ETF issuers must understand how authorized participants create and redeem shares, the role of market makers in facilitating secondary-market trading, and the factors that influence how efficiently their funds trade.  

These include liquidity, bid-ask spreads and the relationship between an ETF’s market price and its NAV. For example, understanding how a corporate action or dividend within the portfolio, or a large creation or redemption order at the fund level, impacts the market price is imperative as an ETF issuer. As the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) explains, ETF shares can trade at a premium or discount to NAV, while bid-ask spreads can increase the cost of buying and selling shares. 

Although market conditions and the liquidity of an ETF’s underlying assets influence these factors, managers need to understand their implications for investors. 

Having access to capital markets expertise from the outset is therefore essential. Managers need to consider how their ETF will trade in practice, rather than focusing exclusively on the performance of its underlying portfolio. 

Attracting investors in an increasingly crowded market 

Even when an ETF launches successfully and operates efficiently, there is no guarantee that it will attract sufficient investment to become commercially viable. According to the Investment Company Institute, 1,280 US ETFs were liquidated or merged between 2015 and 2024, demonstrating that not every fund will remain economically feasible for the issuer. 

Meanwhile, the number of US ETFs continues to grow, rising from 3,641 at the end of 2024 to 4,495 at the end of 2025 with continued considerable growth into 2026. Established providers may benefit from strong brand recognition, extensive distribution networks and substantial resources, making it difficult for new fund sponsors to compete. 

Distribution also presents different challenges from those associated with traditional mutual funds and private funds. Because ETF shares are traded on exchange, issuers do not necessarily have direct relationships with, or complete visibility over, the investors holding their funds. This can make it more difficult to understand their investor base and to develop effective distribution strategies. 

Investment managers therefore need to consider their target audience and how they intend to reach it well before launching a fund. This includes identifying relevant distribution platforms, building relationships with financial advisors and other intermediaries, and determining how their offering will stand out from competing products. 

Without sufficient assets under management, even an ETF with a strong investment strategy may struggle to generate enough revenue to cover its operating expenses. Managers therefore need a credible plan for attracting and retaining investors, rather than relying on the strength of their investment strategy alone. 

Preparing for the operational and regulatory demands 

While the SEC’s introduction of Rule 6c-11 in 2019 made it easier for qualifying ETFs to launch without obtaining individual exemptive orders, this has not removed the regulatory and operational complexities involved in establishing and managing an ETF. 

For managers moving from private funds in particular, there may be a steep learning curve around pre-trade compliance, applicable portfolio diversification and tax requirements, and the regulatory obligations associated with operating a registered investment company.  

Managers must also consider the practical requirements of launching an ETF. This includes arranging seed capital to support the initial creation of ETF shares and establishing the necessary liquidity for trading. Managers need to appoint a distributor, fund administrator, custodian and transfer agent, and other service providers, as well as obtain legal advice and establish appropriate governance arrangements. Partnering with a lead market maker and listing exchange are also imperative when bringing an ETF to market.  

For investment managers unfamiliar with these requirements, the time, cost and expertise involved can be easy to underestimate. Inadequate preparation can lead to compliance failures, operational problems or unexpected costs, potentially undermining a fund’s viability and adversely affecting shareholders. 

Addressing these requirements early in the launch process is essential, and must not be delayed until the fund is ready to begin trading. 

Knowing when to outsource 

Given the range of nuanced capabilities required, investment managers entering the ETF market face an important decision about which functions to manage internally and which to outsource. 

Attempting to build every capability in-house can be expensive, particularly for smaller managers or those launching their first ETF. Even the biggest funds often use external service providers as part of their operating structure. This is because recruiting experts in areas such as capital markets and compliance requires significant investment, with ongoing costs regardless of whether a fund attracts sufficient assets. 

Deciding whether and where to outsource functions such as fund administration, custody, transfer agency, distribution, and legal and compliance functions, can give managers access to established expertise and infrastructure without having to develop these capabilities internally. 

However, outsourcing should not simply be viewed as a way to reduce costs. Managers must consider which capabilities are strategically important to retain internally and where partners can provide greater efficiency or expertise. 

They must also recognize that outsourcing a function does not necessarily remove their responsibility for oversight. Appropriate governance, clear accountability and ongoing monitoring of service providers remain essential. 

In short, managers need an operating model that meets regulatory requirements, supports the fund’s investment strategy and remains commercially sustainable as the business grows. 

Looking beyond launch 

The growth of the US ETF market has created opportunities for investment managers, but easier access has not removed the challenges of operating a successful fund. 

While active and passive ETFs differ in their investment approaches, the fundamental challenges of launching, managing and growing a commercially viable fund are much the same. Managers entering the market need to look beyond their investment strategy and consider how their fund will trade, gather assets, and meet regulatory obligations over the long term. 

By addressing these requirements early and identifying where external support is needed, managers can improve their prospects of competing successfully in an increasingly crowded market. A successful ETF launch is only the beginning; managers must also ensure their fund can attract investors, operate efficiently and remain commercially viable. 

 

MOST READ

PODCAST