FREE email newsletters 
ISE Suggests Displaying Flash Orders to All
Traders Magazine Online News, August 19, 2009
The International Securities Exchange would like the Securities and Exchange Commission to continue to allow flash orders, but with a twist. Instead of disseminating the flash information to a limited audience, that information could be disseminated to everyone, the exchange said.
Doing so would avoid charges that information is seen only by a select group of people, said Gary Katz, CEO of the ISE. Flash orders could also be made optional for all market participants whose orders are about to be routed to a better-priced venue, he said.
"There are changes we could make to how flash orders are disseminated, so that we could continue to provide the benefits of flash orders and remove the concerns that regulators as well as investors in the marketplace have," Katz said. He added that the SEC and the industry "should not jump to ban certain practices" that some investors may want.
Bans, he said, are a drastic measure. "A good analogy is the current process taking place at the SEC on short selling," Katz said. "Instead of banning short selling altogether, the SEC is looking to implement mechanisms to ensure it's being done properly."
The SEC, Katz said, could create a special designation so flash orders in options can be published for all to see by the Options Price Reporting Authority. "Market centers would have to work with the SEC and the industry on how to show those orders," Katz said. "If you showed them and there was no differentiation between them and a quote, that would lock the market. So it would require a thoughtful solution, but it is certainly possible to implement."
A locked market occurs when one market center publishes a bid (offer) at the same price as another market center's offer (bid). Locking another market is not permitted either in equities or options. Flash orders, by definition, are aggressive orders that would lock the market if they're publicly displayed.
BATS Exchange, which offers flash orders in equities, has also argued that these orders should be displayed publicly through the consolidated tape. In a July 30 newsletter, CEO Joe Ratterman said "BATS would prefer that BOLT quotes [its version of flash orders in equities] be publicly disseminated through the consolidated tape. They represent better priced orders and we believe they need to be published widely to the entire industry." Both BATS and Nasdaq OMX Group said earlier this month, in the wake of widespread criticism of flash orders, that they would voluntarily withdraw those order types by Sept. 1.
Ratterman believes locked markets should be allowed by regulators. After pointing out, in his newsletter, that BATS publishes flash order information on the exchange's market data feeds, he noted: "The only place you can't find BOLT orders is in the consolidated tape, and we would post them there too if the regulatory structure allowed it. Simply stated, the BATS implementation made flashed quotes available to as wide an audience as [is] currently allowed by securities law."
More recently, BATS clarified its position. The exchange suggests that marketable orders that seek liquidity only on a particular exchange, rather than those that would otherwise be routed to another market, should be included in the consolidated tape. Orders seeking liquidity on a particular exchange would be cancelled if they do not get filled at the market's best price. BATS does not think routable orders should be delayed by exchanges, even for a few milliseconds.
For more information on related topics, visit the following channels:
