Commentary

Ivy Schmerken
Traders Magazine Online News

MiFID II Transparency Puts Stress on Data Architecture

Buy-side firms are facing huge changes in disclosure and transparency requirements, which could upend their data management architectures, according to this guest commentary from FlexTrade.

Traders Poll

Are you concerned about foreign ownership of a U.S. stock exchange?



Free Site Registration

July 2, 2013

Back to Basics

Ariel Investments' Cheryl Cargie Thinks a Return to Simpler Market Structure Is Needed -- Now

By John D'Antona Jr.

Trading has gotten too complex.

Too many order types. Too many trading venues. Too many algorithms. It's time for the equities market to get back to basics and start fresh. 

#Caption#

That's what trading pro Cheryl Cargie, senior vice president and head trader at Chicago-based Ariel Investments LLC, believes. And that means a return to the "good ol' days" of trading-a simpler time, she said. Her ideal trading ecosystem wouldn't have such things as high-frequency traders, 40-plus trading venues described as "lit" or "dark," or prices quoted in penny or sub-penny increments.

Her ideal trading world would also prohibit exchanges from paying rebates to high-frequency traders. The public stock exchanges would go back to being nonprofit entities, she added. Lastly, there'd be markedly fewer order types.

"I'm all about old-school trading," Cargie said. "If you can end payment for flow and take away the pressure for exchanges to turn a profit, then maybe HFT will go away and real liquidity will come back to the market."

Tough words.

Cargie wants to find natural liquidity easily, and in today's complex market structure, it is harder than ever to find it, she said. Cargie has been in the trading business since 1986. She remembers a simpler market structure, when the floor specialist was a friend and the New York Stock Exchange was "the biggest dark pool" of them all.

That's when she began trading. Armed with a degree in finance, the then-23-year-old received a two-week crash course from anyone who would help.

"The hardest part of this baptism by fire was learning the trading desk language," Cargie recalled. "And the language was spoken in short bursts followed by a hang-up."

Despite the short calls, and after many of these staccato-burst exchanges, Cargie caught onto the language of trading-hitting bids, lifting offerings, butterfly stips and barbell trades. It was pure trading and exciting.

But it was the adrenaline rush of the trading desk-sitting amongst the shouting, the camaraderie, the raw energy of the desk-that captivated her then and now, she said. "In college they never told you what a trading desk was like, but when I got there and took it all in, I knew I wanted to stay."

She began trading shortly after landing a job in the investments department at Combined Insurance at the age of 23. After that, Cargie moved to Fiduciary Management Associates, a small Chicago-based money manager, where she learned the fixed-income business. She learned the trading and operations side of that business, inputting her own trades into the desk's system, and the mechanics of clearing through the Depository Trust Company.

Then, through the trading grapevine, she heard that Ariel Investments was seeking a small-cap trader. The change from fixed-income to equities peaked her interest.

"They put the word out they were looking for a trader, and I got wind of it," Cargie said. That was 1994. She quickly accepted the position and has never looked back.