Storm Copestand
Traders Magazine Online News

Conquering Fear in Trading

In this exclusive to Traders Magazine, therapist Storm Copestand examines how traders can manage expectations and conquer their fear during the entire execution process.

Traders Poll

Amid changes in builder, do you think the CAT project will be completed by 2020?

Free Site Registration

July 1, 2011

Pinball Wizards

Why the deaf, dumb, blind kid can't keep winning forever

By Dan Mathisson

How could a deaf, dumb and blind kid play a mean pinball? I have always found The Who's 1969 classic frustrating: the poor kid can't see or hear, and yet he is blessed with a compensatory talent for... pinball? Couldn't they have given Tommy a more believable talent, like, say, truffle-sniffing? The very strangeness of the song always made me think it must represent something important, but what? Well, after reading a recent newspaper article, I have figured the song's meaning out. Pinball Wizard is about index funds. 

Dan Mathisson

The article that enlightened me was touting the benefits of passive investing. It cited a study showing that in 2010, 65 percent of actively-managed large-cap funds were beaten by the S&P 500 Index ETF, commonly known as the "Spyder." Other studies have shown similar results-after expenses, index funds have beaten more than two-thirds of their peer active funds over the previous 10 years. The index fund managers had superior average performance without using their ears to listen to earnings calls, their mouths to ask questions of corporate management or their eyes to read research reports. Turns out that on Wall Street, the deaf, dumb, blind kid really can play a mean pinball.

How do you think they do it? What makes them so good? Unlike Tommy's strange prowess with the silver ball, the theory behind index funds' superior performance is straightforward: they are what economists call "free-riders." Thanks to the legions of analysts grinding through accounting footnotes late into the night, the passive index investors can assume that all available public information is quickly baked into the stock price without their help, and therefore they don't need to burden themselves with complicated things like earnings forecasts and cash flows.


No Opening Bells

They base their businesses on the concept of market efficiency, which states that the investing pinball will ricochet in such unpredictable ways that playing without even looking is as valid a strategy as trying to predict the ball's path. And that means that passive investors can focus on keeping their operating and transaction costs low. Like the pinball wizard, they ain't got no distractions, don't care about no opening bells, don't see no news a'flashin', don't need to buy or sell.

Investors have bought in. It's been almost 40 years since Burton Malkiel began preaching that index funds were a logical choice in a world of efficient markets, but in the past three years their growth has gone through the roof. According to a Tabb Group study, in 2007, only 21 percent of managed long-only U.S. Equity assets were in passive funds. In just three years, Tabb estimates that this percentage more than doubled, climbing to 44 percent in 2010.