Commentary

Momtchil Pojarliev
Traders Magazine Online News

Some Like It Hedged

BNP Asset Management's Pojarliev discusses a variety of options to address foreign currency exposures. Although there is no single best-practice solution for addressing foreign currency exposures, institutional investors have three main choices, he says.

Traders Poll

Amid changes in builder, do you think the CAT project will be completed by 2020?




Free Site Registration

November 1, 2010

Sellside Bares All

By Peter Chapman

Also in this article

"Fragmentation has made our jobs a lot harder," Tim Fetter, a trader with Eaton Vance, said at STA. "I'd like to see a decrease in the number of trading venues."

 

Order Mishandling

With new dark pools and exchanges coming online regularly, that's unlikely any time soon. As Fetter was speaking, Nasdaq was in the process of launching its new size-focused exchange, Nasdaq OMX PSX, and Instinet was launching its new block-trading dark pool, BLX.

Perhaps compounding the problem for the buyside are charges that certain entities--both brokers and exchanges--have been mishandling their orders. Brokers and exchanges have flashed orders in dark pools and elsewhere, for instance, with an eye toward avoiding exchange fees, giving lurkers in those venues a free look at order flow.

Morgan Stanley, in particular, is critical. "Some of the practices were appalling," Bill Neuberger, Morgan Stanley's co-head of electronic trading, said at STA. "Your finger comes off the mouse. Do you know your order was routed to 400 different guys? No, you had no idea."

The big broker is calling on the SEC to conduct a wholesale revamping of order-handling practices, singling out such activities as blind pinging and the use of "actionable" indications of interest. These "free look for a free execution" practices leak clients' valuable trading information, Morgan Stanley told the SEC in March.

According to Neuberger, it is practices like these that have imbued the sellside-buyside relationship with mistrust. Like Goldman, Morgan Stanley is also calling for more transparency of order-routing practices. To "help regain the trust," Neuberger believes the order-handling broker must make clear not only where it is routing customer orders but "how many swings and misses did you have? How many different people did you route to before you actually got an execution?" he said at STA.

 

In Control

Reports to the buyside are not enough, says Gary Ardell of ConvergEx. Buyside traders must also feel they are in control. "If people get a bad print, they want to know where it came from," Ardell said at STA. Once they learn, they sometimes ask Ardell to remove that particular dark pool from his company's Abraxas routing platform, he said. "People ask us all the time to remove certain dark pools and emphasize others," he said. "It goes a long way in letting people feel they not only understand what is going on with their orders, but that they are absolutely in control."

Limiting the trading venues to which their orders travel is part of the program at Barclays Capital, as well. According to Brian Fagen, Barclays' head of equities electronic trading sales, the big broker lets its customers create "tiers and segments" within the vast trading world against which they want to execute their orders. "We show them the performance of their order flow," he said at STA. "They base their decisions on facts."

All of this looking under the hood is necessary, according to those on the buyside. "There has to be much more transparency in the creation of the order," Damian Maroun, head trader at GE Asset Management, said at STA. "It has to be fed back into our systems so we can see in real time where we are having success."

 

(c) 2010 Traders Magazine and SourceMedia, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

http://www.tradersmagazine.com http://www.sourcemedia.com/