Commentary

Tim Quast
Traders Magazine Online News

We're All HFTs Now

In this guest commentary, author Tim Quast looks back at the history of HFT and how the market has evolved to where many firms now fit the definition of high-frequency trader.

Traders Poll

Are you in favor of a pilot program and examination of the rebate system by the SEC?




Free Site Registration

June 2, 2009

SEC's Short-Selling Decision Nears

By Nina Mehta

Also in this article

  • SEC's Short-Selling Decision Nears

In two weeks, the comment period covering the Securities and Exchange Commission's proposal to reintroduce restrictions around short selling will end. The SEC, as part of a rewrite of Regulation SHO, sought input from the industry, issuers and the general public. Opinions are all over the place, and there is no shortage of handicappers.

On the table are five separate proposals. One involves bringing back Rule 10a-1, or the New York Stock Exchange's "uptick" rule, rescinded by the SEC in 2007. Another would introduce a price test using the national best bid as the reference price. Three others involve a circuit breaker that would trigger a trading restriction around short sales if a stock's price declines by a certain amount.

While some in the industry are advocating that the SEC do nothing, far more are betting that the Commission will take action. If so, the choice for the SEC appears to be between a bid test and a circuit breaker that leads to a bid test. The uptick option has been condemned by exchanges and broker-dealers as irrelevant in a fast-paced decimal environment.

Rick Ketchum

 The SEC has also said that bids are more accurate reflections of current prices than ticks, which have 90 seconds to print to the tape. Issuers generally advocate the bid test, while the trading industry would settle for a circuit breaker that leads to a bid test.

For the SEC, the issue isn't easy. The two current Republican commissioners are on record questioning whether any SEC action to curtail short selling is necessary. The SEC's Office of Economic Analysis, whose data and studies, along with those from outside academics, led to the Commission's elimination of all price tests for short sales, is believed to be against a change. The SEC staff is also rumored to be against new restrictions.

But the SEC is under pressure from both Capitol Hill and Main Street. Roel Campos, a former SEC commissioner who left the agency in 2007, predicts that the Commission will "probably decide on some version of the price or bid [test], but I don't know that they'll choose a circuit breaker." Campos, now a partner at Cooley Godward Kronish, spoke at a Security Traders Association conference last month. Tom Gira, executive vice president of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, said at another conference that a stock-specific circuit breaker that leads to a ban on shorts is the likelier outcome.

William O'Brien