Rob Daly
Traders Magazine Online News

OPINION: CAT NMS is Out of Options

The SROs have no choice but to meet their deadlines.

Traders Poll

Are you ready to comply with the new updates required by the amended Rule 606?

Free Site Registration

July 31, 1999

Back to Basics for Hotshot Trading System With Volume Below Expectations, OptiMark Under Pressure

By Monica Simms

Also in this article

  • Back to Basics for Hotshot Trading System With Volume Below Expectations, OptiMark Under Pressure
  • Page 2

Since the January debut of the OptiMark Trading System, officials of the Durango, Colo.-based company that designed the machine, say it is making headway in the crowded field of alternative trading systems (ATS). As evidence, OptiMark proudly cites the 650 traders who regularly use the system, as well as the 2,000 traders schooled to use the superanonymous black box-style computer.

To be sure, these numbers compare favorably with the rival ATS subspecies known as electronic communications networks. The Island ECN operated by Iselin, N.J.-based Datek Online Holdings, for instance, has some 200 users connected, though it is largely targeting retail trades and not the institutional customers OptiMark mostly wants.


OptiMark, meanwhile, is preparing to set up a home with Nasdaq, which would transform OptiMark into a super ATS. In theory, the move would allow it to handle Nasdaq institutional order flow with less chance of market impact. OptiMark's computers will be stabled at Nasdaq's computer hub in Trumball, Conn.

Given that ECNs handle about 30 percent of all Nasdaq trades - up from 24 percent in the past two years - OptiMark comes at a critical juncture in Nasdaq's history. Whether its planned introduction on Nasdaq later this year turns into sweet revenge for Nasdaq, allowing it to suck back some of the order flow diverted to ECNs, remains to be seen.

Reuters Group's Instinet, which handles about 15 percent of Nasdaq trades, would appear to be the most vulnerable to attack from OptiMark, simply because both target the institutional business. Whether Instinet's recent stake in Archipelago, operated by Chicago-based Archipelago Holdings, will change the equation, is another remaining mystery.

Dark Side

Despite the bright possibilities, however, a more significant number hides a darker side of OptiMark.

OptiMark is still lagging its early transaction projections, executing only one million shares daily, instead of the anticipated two million to five million shares projected, according to published reports.

The momentum that OptiMark is likely to gain should its integration with Nasdaq take place, must also be measured against the mixed reviews for OptiMark by institutional traders.

At issue are concerns largely about OptiMark's ease of use. OptiMark officials do not deny that OptiMark is complicated for the average trader.

"Instead of teaching [traders] everything about what the OptiMark system can do, we now teach what works for the particular trader or set of traders," said OptiMark Chief Executive Phillip Riese.

The Hallmark

OptiMark's hallmark is a sophisticated profiling capability, which enables users to graphically depict scaled multi-order trades. This allows a trader to draw a profile or to select from several templates that represent commonly deployed trading strategies such as All' or Nothing' block trades. OptiMark also enables users to peg profiles to benchmarks, such as the current bid or ask price, which should make it unnecessary to re-enter profile parameters as the markets move.

Some traders do speak favorably about OptiMark's ease of use.

"I find it very easy for putting an order into," said Mike Cormack, the head trader at Kansas City-based American Century, a mutual fund giant that is a partial investor in OptiMark. Cormack and several other traders at his firm, were trained to use OptiMark sitting at their desks in Kansas.